Home / Publications / Opinions & Editorials / Budget Changes Give Welcome Encouragement to Competition in fnance
- Media Releases
- Opinions & Editorials
- |
Budget Changes Give Welcome Encouragement to Competition in fnance
Summary:
| Citation | Kronick, Jeremy, and MacKenzie, Peter, and Mawakina Bafale. 2026. Budget Changes Give Welcome Encouragement to Competition in fnance. Opinions & Editorials. Toronto: C.D. Howe Institute. |
| Page Title: | Budget Changes Give Welcome Encouragement to Competition in fnance – C.D. Howe Institute |
| Article Title: | Budget Changes Give Welcome Encouragement to Competition in fnance |
| URL: | https://cdhowe.org/publication/budget-changes-give-welcome-encouragement-to-competition-in-fnance/ |
| Published Date: | November 17, 2026 |
| Accessed Date: | November 17, 2026 |
Authors
Outline
Outline
For all media inquiries, including requests for reports or interviews:
Published in Financial Post
By Jeremy Kronick, Peter MacKenzie and Mawakina Bafale
Regulator gets mandate to ease burden on new entrants, which should help innovation
Post-budget discussion usually focuses on big things like the deficit or multibillion-dollar items like the “productivity mega deduction” and loses sight of less glamorous but still meaningful changes.
The recent federal budget included a couple of such changes in the financial services sector, especially the addition of a competitiveness objective to the mandate of the Office of the Superintendent of Financial Institutions (OSFI) and the long-awaited launch of Payments Canada’s “real-time rail.” Both will help modernize the financial services industry in Canada.
Canadians’ long-standing preference for safety and stability in the country’s financial sector has served us well. Our having come through the 2008 financial crisis relatively unscathed compared to many other countries is often attributed to this “safety-first” approach. But, like everything, emphasizing safety and stability has a cost: it constrains competition and the innovation and growth that competition engenders.
By rebalancing our regulatory approach, it’s very likely we can get more innovation and growth in the financial sector without sacrificing much in the way of stability. One indicator of the current imbalance: more than 90 per cent of the written materials Canada’s financial regulators issue target safety and stability, while fewer than 20 per cent look to improve growth and innovation (some do both). A 2024 survey of financial firms found that nearly three-quarters of employees had to spend at least some of their time on compliance duties, with the burden falling heaviest on small institutions.
The need to rebalance our approach has only grown as a result of the current tensions with our now often confounding southern neighbour. Canadians want greater control over their economy, be it through attracting more foreign investment or domestic policy changes.
There were signs before the budget that this rebalancing was beginning. In June, OSFI introduced streamlined approval for new entrants, consolidating more than 600 pages of guidance in an effort to modernize its supervisory framework. To encourage more lending to small and medium-sized businesses, its new capital rules also reduced the standardized risk weight for those loans from 85 to 75 per cent. Whether the reduction should have been larger can be debated but the lower requirement will allow banks to hold less capital against such loans, which will improve the economics of financing businesses.
The budget takes further steps toward rebalancing. Beyond the overriding objective of assuring regulated institutions are resilient, it proposes giving OSFI a “secondary competition objective” to “help ensure that competition considerations, such as proportionality, compliance burden, and market impacts, are more clearly and consistently reflected in how OSFI regulates and supervises financial institutions.” The language doesn’t say OSFI should encourage competition, but if that is what the government intends, OSFI has an opportunity to structure future regulation in a way that generates increased productivity.
What does all this look like in practice, and what steps are still needed? OSFI making adjustments to improve the proportionality of regulation means the burden will be tailored more to financial institutions’ size and risk profile, which should allow them to compete more effectively.
Competition requires letting institutions enter the market and grow. Lengthy, uncertain approvals discourage that. The budget includes several proposals to reduce that problem: a one-year timeline for decisions on applications from new financial institutions; clearer support for credit unions entering the federal framework; and changes to help federal credit unions access capital. The budget’s boost in the maximum coverage for deposit insurance from $100,000 to $250,000 — while not without risk, notably moral hazard concerns that come from increased protection — should also help smaller deposit-taking institutions compete for funding.
The long-delayed “real-time rail” has now been launched, with the budget announcing further plans for modernizing the payment system. Eight institutions have connected so far and Payments Canada expects the system to reach more than nine in 10 Canadians within a year. This ultra-fast payment system, which brings Canada onside with its G7 peers, allows participating institutions to clear and settle payments around the clock, with funds immediately available to recipients. Costly forms of payments such as cheques will be used less (or removed altogether) and businesses will have access to payments sooner. For households, insurance disbursements and government payouts, among other things, will be made faster by this system.
As we outlined in a recent C.D. Howe Institute roadmap, there is much more OSFI can do to boost competition and investment, including faster approval of banks’ internal model changes, supervision that is more transparent, and capital rules that are more suited to credit unions’ co-operative structures.
But the budget does propose welcome steps toward modernizing Canada’s financial services industry. A more efficient financial sector means more capital available to the economy. The next step, and where the rubber hits the road, is implementation.
Related Publications
- Research
- Intelligence Memos


