Home / Publications / Intelligence Memos / Bill C-39 Doesn’t Mean Durable Investor Certainty
- Media Releases
- Intelligence Memos
- |
Bill C-39 Doesn’t Mean Durable Investor Certainty
Summary:
| Citation | Kate Koplovich. 2026. Bill C-39 Doesn’t Mean Durable Investor Certainty. Intelligence Memos. Toronto: C.D. Howe Institute. |
| Page Title: | Bill C-39 Doesn’t Mean Durable Investor Certainty – C.D. Howe Institute |
| Article Title: | Bill C-39 Doesn’t Mean Durable Investor Certainty |
| URL: | https://cdhowe.org/publication/bill-c-39-doesnt-mean-durable-investor-certainty/ |
| Published Date: | November 18, 2026 |
| Accessed Date: | November 18, 2026 |
Outline
Outline
Related Topics
For all media inquiries, including requests for reports or interviews:
To: Major project watchers
From: Kate Koplovich
Date: November 18, 2026
Re: Bill C-39 Doesn’t Mean Durable Investor Certainty
Bill C-39, the Building Canada Strong Act, which the federal government tabled last month, does improve the country’s laws on project approvals, but there is more Ottawa could do to create real and lasting certainty for investors.
Though the bill makes changes to six separate acts, what’s most important are four changes to the Impact Assessment Act, which, in some circles, became known as the no more pipelines act.
C-39 adds the Canadian Nuclear Safety Commission (CNSC) and Canada Energy Regulator (CER) as responsible authorities to conduct impact assessments for some projects regulated under the Nuclear Safety and Control Act and the Canadian Energy Regulator Act. Empowering the CNSC and CER to lead, and in some cases make the final decision on impact assessments for nuclear, uranium, and interprovincial pipeline and transmission projects ensures expert regulators lead these processes and removes the requirement for a joint review panel with the Impact Assessment Agency. In practice, it’s also likely to speed things up simply because the CER, for example, consistently delivers its work on time. A recent C.D. Howe Institute report found that review panels are the most time-consuming type of impact assessment.
A second big change is to allow enabling work to begin on projects even before the government issues a decision. In theory, this will reduce the time between application and construction, which means also reducing the time before proponents start realizing revenues and profits. In practice, however, proponents may want to await final approval to reduce the risk of legal challenges from affected communities.
Bill C-39 also significantly reduces time limits for reviews. For example, where the current impact assessment regime has a time limit of three years for proponents to provide all necessary documentation, Bill C-39 mandates 365 days. And it wants assessments completed in 300 days, with the possibility of reducing that. By contrast, the current act allows the option of lengthening the process. Of course, time limits can always be extended. Meeting them relies on proponents providing complete submissions upfront and regulators and agencies leveraging institutional knowledge and past assessments to streamline delivery of recommendations and conditions.
Finally, impact assessment decisions will now include required authorizations from other federal agencies and departments. It is not quite clear in reality how these authorizations can be approved using project information received from proponents for their impact assessments unless project proponents collect much more detailed information upfront. But this change seems likely to force improved coordination and information-sharing between the Impact Assessment Agency and federal departments responsible for those authorizations, and that’s a positive development.
Shortening timelines is only one piece of the regulatory puzzle, however. Considerable uncertainty remains because approvals are increasingly political, assessments involve a long list of criteria unrelated to direct project impacts and there’s always the risk of litigation.
The Impact Assessment Act still requires ministerial or Cabinet approval of projects, which puts projects at the mercy of politics. And both the Impact Assessment Act and Canadian Energy Regulator Act include long lists of factors against which proponents are assessed – including many policy and ideological objectives that don’t belong in such reviews (like climate change, sustainability and the intersection of sex and gender with other identity factors). Hearings and assessments can still end up focusing on tangential effects rather than projects’ more direct effects on the environment, safety, and Indigenous consultation. Time-constrained hearings on ill-defined effects could easily bring legal challenges from affected communities.
The required “duty to consult” is not a veto on projects, but many Indigenous Nations are already stretched beyond their capacity when it comes to engagement and consultations. A Crown Consultation Hub, proposed as part of the Cabinet directive released alongside C-39, is a positive development, but C-39 will certainly test the Crown’s ability to fulfill its duty within the shortened timelines.
Bill C-39’s changes should be just the beginning of a much-needed overhaul of Canada’s regulatory system. There are still serious problems regarding certainty for proponents and investors, including litigation risk. Depoliticizing reviews, focusing on direct project effects and increasing the Crown’s ability to fulfill its duty to consult would make Canada’s regulatory system more predictable and durable.
Kate Koplovich is the C.D. Howe Institute’s Calgary-based senior policy analyst.
To send a comment or leave feedback, email us at blog@cdhowe.org.
The views expressed here are those of the author. The C.D. Howe Institute does not take corporate positions on policy matters.
A version of this Memo first appeared in the Financial Post.
Related Publications
- Intelligence Memos
- Intelligence Memos
- Intelligence Memos
