What explains this gap between principle and practice? The immediate reason is that under the current policy, value-for-money assessments are optional, not mandatory. But that prompts a further question: why do evaluators generally choose not to conduct them? One explanation is that they’re complex, requiring specialized data systems and technical expertise that departments do not have and would take time and resources to develop.
Why don’t politicians insist that departments build the capacity required to assess all federal programs through a value-for-money lens? One possibility is that, while agreeing with such assessments in principle, politicians balk once they realize they would limit their discretion to use spending to win elections. In “normal” times, ministers don’t see any electoral upside to providing evidence that programs they are responsible for — or, even worse, programs they have championed and implemented — aren’t working.
Ministers have good reason to be concerned about drawing attention to underperforming programs. In a 2024 paper published by the School of Public Policy at the University of Calgary, I found that many government programs, particularly business subsidies, would fail a value-for-money test. That’s a discouraging conclusion but it also represents an opportunity for ambitious ministers and officials. Eliminating or reforming poorly performing programs would allow the current federal government to pursue its agenda of investing in a stronger economy and more robust national security without raising taxes or adding much to our already high debt.
The timing is therefore right to put value-for-money assessments into practice. Coincidentally or not, Ottawa’s evaluation policy is now under review. Bold reform could dramatically increase the value Canadians receive from federal spending. In our recent C.D. Howe Institute report, Benoît Robidoux and I set out a comprehensive plan for achieving this goal.
Our key recommendation is to make value-for-money assessments mandatory, using a framework that captures all the benefits and costs of a program, private and social. Another important recommendation is to require that new spending programs pass a simplified value-for-money test. In practice, this would make existing approvals more rigorous by applying a benefit-cost framework.
Finally, we recommend that Ottawa set up an independent “evaluator-general” to help build departmental evaluation capacity but also to undertake evaluations while departments are getting up to speed. The EG would also be able to challenge departmental evaluations and undertake evaluations of programs administered by more than one department.
Conducting and publishing value-for-money assessments would allow all Canadians, not just politicians, to have an informed opinion about the worth of federal programs. A better-informed electorate could support better policy choices and increase politicians’ incentive to fix programs that are not working — which would be good for our democracy.
“Value for money” is a principle everyone accepts. We need to close the gap between principle and practice.